Pandoryk's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[-Staggering-]

So original!

Hey, don't give up if you don't have a decent score. I dunno why but when music is different, original, not like all this stuff we already know, there are a lot of people that have one mission "vote 0 or 1".
I like it, I'm not fan, I can't listen to this all day long, but I really like the work you've done. Keep it up!

The-Scarecrow responds:

Yeah, I know how it is, people are afraid of new things :]

Thanks.

[panda juice]

It's ok!

It would have been better than that in my opinion. Actually, it's too simple and not enough emotional or marginal. Sure you can do something extremely curious and interesting with that.
The end is already cool but the end of the end seems to vanish somewhere and I'm disappointed of that.
So work on it again! ;)

stephenharper responds:

its not a project i can go back and work on again, just a one shot thing, with the tones

[Cello Concerto no. 1 1st mvnt]

Nice work

That's really nice. A good classical piece.
I can imagine a story, characters, a face to face, kind of victory but not total.
Unfortunately, I can't catch the little fantasy, what we call in french le "je-ne-sais-quoi" that makes this music THE music.
But anyway, that's cool. And you made a beautiful (and a bit mysterious) ending! ^^

MusicalRocky responds:

A good classical piece, pretty much what I was aiming for : D

Victory, eh? More a conflict. You see, the way I imagine this, the first movement (this) is a conflict (B theme is hope), the 2nd movement is the people's faith in a positive outcome of the conflict, and victory. The 3rd movement (which I will write hopefully soon) will be the return of evil, another huge conflict, and then eternal victory for all. Sounds cheesy, but that's what it is. :)

The fantasy? Haha, je ne sais quoi means I don't know what, right? :P that's cool. But yeah I know what kind of thing you're talking about, though I think it is present in this mvnt.

The ending is very powerful, and it's still minor, and it sounds like loud and strong. Evil is still present, but a sort of turning point in the conflict has been reached. Thus, the 2nd mvnt.

Anyways, thanks for reviewing :) I'm glad you had those images in your mind.

Rocky

[Anton]

Glad I liked it!

I have no words to express the feeling that this music is giving to me right now again and again. Thank you so much!

Erkie responds:

:D

More where that came from.

[Thracian-Jazz]

Wonderful!

That's a music full of colors, emotions.

I feel sadness at a the beginning, as if someone important disappeared or has to go in another country to follow a kind of dangerous destiny, and then I see some hope with a boat far away on the sea. So I think that this person can be on the boat, and I have the opportunity to escape my new life without this person. But, the time after that. I start to follow the boat, flying in the sky, but I'm not enough fast to catch it up. BTW I find myself in a city, in a antique city to be exact, looking for this person everywhere, but I can't find her, and I understand that it's over.

That's surely not perfect english right here so please excuse me ^^ but, eh, that's what I feel when I listen to your song, good job!

sorohanro responds:

thanx
this is one of the most artistic reviews i recived.
sad story ... needs happy ending, i love happy endings in real life ;)

i find myself looking for a certain person all my life and maby all my past lifes, looking in ancient citys, modern ones ... well, isn't over, cause i found her ... again ...
more problematic is keeping ...

i like your story, i might write a song inspired by it.

[Darklife of Sil]

Heavily cinematic

I'm listening to your stuff for about 2 hours right now, some are really nice, others can be a bit improved and one thing nice is that we can quickly recognize your style. You're making music with personnality (And a lot of NG users should take example from you).
If I was a great flash creator, I would like to use this song for a masterpiece. BTW I'm not enough great to use this music right now. Maybe in several months ^^ maybe later, maybe never. BTW I encourage any great flash artist to dl your song and make a movie with it.
And to finish my review, you know, anybody doesn't "see" the same thing than you, so don't be rude if the result (if it arrives one day) isn't what you've expected! ^^

Bosa responds:

Hm.. I'm taking your words in to consideration. I was actually expecting a lot in this song, but I suppose patience is the key to success here.

-Bosa

[Bosa Christmas 2006]

Simply great

Nothing to improve in my opinion, so what more can I say?
Oh yes, I know :
- Wonderful work! - ^^

Bosa responds:

Took the words right out of my mouth, he did.

-Bosa

[Bowser castle ( NSMB )]

Agréable

Pas mal du tout! ;)
Assez fidèle, avec ce côté "hanté" à la Castlevania comme les autres le soulignent. Beau travail, même si ça fait plus d'un an que c'est sur NG maintenant... arf, je m'y prends un peu tard. Mais bon c'est le geste qui compte.

Gorekiller responds:

Heeee merci ! Je n'aurais jamais cru que tu irais écouter cette vieillerie qui existe sur NG depuis maintenant plus d' 1 an. Ta revue est réellement appréciable !

[City of Johnson]

Sad

Well, I was expecting a jazzy music full of colors... but this song is very sad. That's beautiful, the end is a bit strange, but eh good job! ^^

Bosa responds:

Thanks, I think I'm full of surprises sometimes..

-Bosa (Just my opinion)

[Roxanne Remake Unplugged]

This jazzy side...

... is WOUAAAAAOUUUUU !!!
See what I mean? That's splendid! I have the impression to be in front of tv, watching "new idol" or something like that, and being absolutely impressed by such a remake and such a voice (obviously). Congratulations!

Inka-Wall responds:

Thank you pandoryk! I'd really love that